Smackdown Vs. Raw 2009 Carrer Mode Glitch?

In SvR09 carrer mode i am on getting my first title and i got a five start match rating in each superstar then i go to challenge the for a No.1 contender match and i chose a random peson, i choose JBL and when i win i get a five start match rating but i still cant challenge for the iC title, i have beaten CM pUnk, JBL and Chuck Palumbo in both No.1 Contender and normal match and still got 5 stars and it still doesnt unlock?